The Supreme Court's full bench will deliver its ruling at 4 p.m. on Nov. 19 in the appeal of former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo, who received 15 years at the appellate level for serious duties in an insurrection tied to the Dec. 3 martial law. The date falls one day before his detention expires on Nov. 20, and the court converted what had been a deliberation session into a ruling date, drawing mixed interpretations in legal circles.
According to the Kyunghyang Shinmun, the Supreme Court on Nov. 16 set the ruling in Han's case for 4 p.m. on Nov. 19. That day had been scheduled as the full bench's second deliberation session, following the first on Sept. 29. A court official said setting a ruling date means the justices have reached agreement.
광고 문의 · 300×250Han's detention at the appeal stage ends on Nov. 20. The maximum detention period at this stage is six months, and the court renewed his detention twice after receiving the case on May 18. With the ruling set for the day before expiry, the prospect of his release without a verdict has effectively vanished.
23 years, then 15, and co-defendant Lee Sang-min's case split off
According to the weekly Kyunghyang, Han is accused of recommending a Cabinet meeting so the martial law declaration would appear to have gone through Cabinet deliberation, and of trying to collect ministers' signatures afterward. Indicted without detention in August 2025, he was sentenced to 23 years and taken into custody at his first trial on Jan. 21 this year, and the appeals court reduced the term to 15 years on May 7.
In August the Supreme Court sent the case to the full bench together with that of former Interior Minister Lee Sang-min, citing public interest and the co-defendant relationship. But Kyunghyang reported that Lee's case is not on the Nov. 19 docket. According to Yonhap, Lee was sentenced to seven years at trial and nine years on appeal, and his detention expires on Dec. 18.
If the court rejects the appeal, the 15-year sentence becomes final. If it overturns the ruling and remands the case, the Seoul High Court can renew his detention. The Hankook Ilbo noted that a remand would allow detention to be extended by up to six more months.
Reacting to release criticism? Court office says review was thorough
Roh Kyung-pil, head of the National Court Administration, told an emergency session of the National Assembly Legislation and Judiciary Committee on Nov. 16 that a draft judgment is circulating among the justices and a ruling date is set once all agree. He said he understood the justices had done their utmost to finish deliberations within the detention period. He attributed the delay to related cases that arrived in late October and had to be reviewed together.
The Democratic Party had sharply criticized the court for missing deadlines set by the insurrection special act, and the special counsel team led by Cho Eun-suk filed an opinion on Nov. 5 urging a prompt ruling. The Hankook Ilbo reported that some legal experts said the timing, right after political criticism, made it look like the court bowed to outside pressure, while the court maintains it followed its practice of setting rulings on the Monday of the week of a regular ruling day.
Han also faces a separate trial over the alleged failure to appoint and the nomination of Constitutional Court justices. The first-instance verdict in that case is due on Nov. 30 at the Seoul Central District Court, where the special counsel has sought five years. The Nov. 19 decision will be the first final judicial ruling arising from the Dec. 3 martial law, drawing close political attention.