The UN General Assembly’s Third Committee adopted its annual North Korea human rights resolution by vote on Nov. 18, local time, with the United States, a co-sponsor every year since 2005, abstaining for the first time. Washington said its request to remove references to the International Criminal Court was not accepted.
According to the Chosun Ilbo and Newsis, the Third Committee in New York adopted the resolution by 95 votes in favor, 14 against and 58 abstentions. The text has usually passed by consensus without a vote, but this year it went to a recorded vote at Washington’s request. The US had co-sponsored the resolution annually since it was first adopted in 2005.
광고 문의 · 300×250In a statement, the US mission said it had sought deletion of ICC references in this and other negotiations but its requests were not reflected. It added that the human rights situation in North Korea remains very serious and that the change in its position does not reflect any assessment of conditions inside the country. The explanation frames the abstention as a dispute over ICC wording rather than the substance of the resolution.
How the votes split, and Seoul’s role
South Korea, Japan, Britain, Germany, France and Australia voted in favor, while North Korea, China, Russia, Iran and Vietnam voted against. South Korea, a co-sponsor this year, reportedly helped add language calling for dialogue and engagement with Pyongyang including inter-Korean talks, progress on humanitarian issues such as abductees, detainees, prisoners of war and separated families, and greater North Korean engagement with UN human rights mechanisms.
Newsis noted that President Trump has hinted at a possible meeting with Kim Jong Un on the sidelines of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China. Some read the abstention as linked to creating conditions for US-North Korea talks, though that is not the reason Washington has given.
The resolution still awaits a vote in the General Assembly plenary. With Seoul and Washington, long aligned on North Korean human rights, casting different votes for the first time, attention is turning to the plenary vote and how the allies will coordinate their human rights diplomacy.