An appellate court on Nov. 18 upheld a lower-court ruling that cancelled the basic plan for Saemangeum International Airport, finding that bird-strike risks and environmental impacts were not properly assessed at the site-selection stage. Environmental groups declared that ‘life has won’ and urged the project be halted.
According to the Kyunghyang Shinmun, the appeals court on Wednesday dismissed the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport’s appeal and let stand the first-instance decision voiding the airport’s basic development plan. The court found that aviation safety and environmental protection had not been adequately considered. Its central reasons were the failure to properly evaluate bird-strike risk when choosing the site and an insufficient environmental review.
광고 문의 · 300×250The suit was filed in September 2022 by 1,297 citizens taking part in a civic coalition seeking to scrap the airport. The Seoul Administrative Court ruled for the plaintiffs on Sept. 11 last year, saying the ministry had grossly underestimated bird-strike risk and failed to examine effects on the Seocheon tidal flats about 7 km away. As reported by the Korea Economic Daily, the lower court also questioned why the project was exempted from a preliminary feasibility study despite a benefit-cost ratio of just 0.479.
Fears of a prolonged stall, and a wrinkle for the tri-port plan
Designated in 2019 as exempt from the feasibility study, the 826.8 billion won project called for a 2,500-meter runway and a passenger terminal, with an opening targeted for 2029. Two consecutive court defeats make delays unavoidable. Kyunghyang cited observers who say that even if the ministry and North Jeolla province appeal, the Supreme Court reviews only questions of law, making it hard to overturn the appellate court’s factual findings.
If the ruling becomes final, the project could not proceed on the existing plan, and correcting the defects identified by the courts could force a rethink of the site and the plan itself. The province has promoted a ‘tri-port’ logistics network linking rail, sea and air as Saemangeum’s core advantage. Analysts say uncertainty over logistics infrastructure could also weigh on Hyundai Motor Group’s announced 9 trillion won investment in the area.
Activists urge no appeal; province weighs its options
The anti-airport coalition held a press conference outside the court right after the ruling, calling on the government to forgo an appeal and halt the project. Co-chair Kim Ji-eun said Gadeok Island’s new airport and Jeju’s second airport also face high bird-strike risks and that the ruling could affect those projects. Co-chair Oh Dong-pil said the government had failed to present meaningful counter-evidence during the trial.
The provincial government expressed regret at failing to meet residents’ hopes and said it would review responses including an appeal. Governor Lee Won-taek called the airport a long-held aspiration of the region and vowed to work with the central government on ways to build it while safeguarding safety and the environment. During the first trial the ministry argued that substitute habitats and bird-control systems could manage the risk, so its decision on an appeal is being closely watched.