Korea’s revised School Health and Education Environment Protection Act, which allows rallies aimed at discriminating against, insulting or denigrating people over national origin to be restricted within 200 meters of a school, takes effect on December 16. Chinese schools and ethnic Chinese residents, unsettled by an anti-China rally in Incheon’s Chinatown in September, are watching how it will work in practice.
The National Assembly passed the amendment at a plenary session on August 20. According to reports at the time by the Digital Times and the education outlet Educhang, the amendment creates a cooperation procedure between police and schools to restrict outdoor rallies and demonstrations that threaten students’ right to learn within ‘education environment protection zones’, which extend 200 meters from a school’s boundary. The law takes effect three months after promulgation, and the Kyeongin Ilbo put the date at December 16.
광고 문의 · 300×250Under the revised law, police chiefs must notify the school principal without delay when a rally or demonstration is filed within a protection zone. If the principal judges that it clearly threatens the right to learn, the principal must ask police to take order-keeping measures such as a notice of prohibition or restriction. The grounds listed include a purpose of discriminating against, insulting or denigrating people because of national origin, expected serious noise, and repeated use of profanity, verbal abuse or slurs.
Unease Left by the Incheon Chinatown Rally
The ethnic Chinese community has its reasons for paying attention. According to the Kyeongin Ilbo, on September 13 the group Incheon Freedom Solidarity held a rally around Chinatown, including Incheon Station plaza and the entrance to Jayu Park, nominally to mark the 76th anniversary of the Incheon Landing. Participants marched through Chinatown chanting slogans against the Chinese Communist Party and tore up North Korean and Chinese flags in the station plaza.
Near Chinatown stands the Incheon Overseas Chinese Elementary School and Zhongshan Middle and High School, attended by ethnic Chinese students. The Kyeongin Ilbo quoted its principal as worrying that students could be hurt by the harsh rhetoric. A vice president of the Incheon Overseas Chinese Association said local ethnic Chinese have no direct connection to anti-China protests, but that some residents were frightened or shaken by the hostility they saw. Most ethnic Chinese in the area descend from those who settled between 1884 and the 1992 normalization of Korea-China ties, and many hold Republic of China (Taiwan) nationality.
Similar episodes occurred in Seoul. Citing Yonhap, the Digital Times said anti-China rallies near some Seoul schools caused controversy last year, and that after rallies in front of the Chinese Embassy in Myeong-dong were banned in July and September last year, the group moved to Daerim-dong, an area with many ethnic Korean Chinese residents. Educhang also recounted how, when an anti-Chinese protest was announced outside a Seoul middle school last September, the principal wrote to the local police chief and district head asking them to stop it.
Partisan Clash and Open Questions
The legislative path was rocky. Lead sponsor Ko Min-jung of the Democratic Party said the law would serve as a ‘minimum safety device’ against hate rallies near schools. The People Power Party agreed with protecting the right to learn but argued that the law’s fundamental aim was to ban anti-China rallies. The original bill targeted ‘discrimination and hate’, but after criticism that ‘hate’ was legally vague, the wording became ‘discrimination, insult and denigration’. The ruling party pushed the bill through the Education Committee alone on March 24, after which it stalled for a time before the plenary.
When the bill passed, the Education Ministry said it expected the law to protect students’ right to learn more fully and help create a safe school environment. Because the system depends on principals judging the risk and police accepting their requests, however, how on-the-ground criteria are set is seen as the key. Debate over balancing the measure against freedom of expression is also likely to continue.
Yoon Young-do, head of the East Asian Research Institute at Sungkonghoe University, told the Kyeongin Ilbo that young people who encountered China only indirectly during the decade of severed exchanges after the 2016 THAAD deployment are prone to unfounded misunderstandings and hostility. He urged politicians to stop exploiting anti-China sentiment and citizens to view China objectively. With Chinese schools in Seoul, Incheon, Busan and elsewhere located in the heart of their cities, how far the law will protect ethnic Chinese students on their way to class is worth watching.