The International Court of Justice will deliver its merits judgment on Nov. 19 in The Gambia’s genocide case against Myanmar over the Rohingya. The final ruling, seven years after the case was filed, will be closely watched for how the court defines genocidal intent, a question that could shape other pending cases including South Africa’s case against Israel over Gaza.
According to Taiwan’s Liberty Times on Nov. 15, international attention is focused as much on the legal test the court will set out as on the verdict itself. The case concerns the military campaign Myanmar’s army launched in August 2017 in northern Rakhine State. Reuters counts at least 730,000 Rohingya who fled to Bangladesh, and refugees have testified to killings, sexual violence and the burning of villages.
광고 문의 · 300×250The Gambia, backed by the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, filed the case in November 2019, alleging breaches of the 1948 Genocide Convention. The court ordered provisional measures in January 2020 requiring Myanmar to prevent genocidal acts and preserve evidence, and rejected Myanmar’s preliminary objections in July 2022. Public hearings on the merits, including the examination of witnesses and experts, ran from Jan. 12 to 29 this year.
Proving the intent to destroy
Genocide requires proof of a specific intent to destroy a protected group in whole or in part. The Gambia argued that intent can be inferred from a pattern of conduct, including the destruction of Rohingya social cohesion and culture and forced displacement. Myanmar countered that the operations were a counterterrorism response to attacks by the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army and that there is no direct evidence of genocidal intent.
In Bosnia v. Serbia (2007) and Croatia v. Serbia (2015), the court applied a strict test under which intent inferred from circumstantial evidence must be the only reasonable inference. An analysis published by the legal blog Opinio Juris noted that the standard of proof repeatedly surfaced in judges’ questions during the January hearings. Eleven countries, including Canada, Britain, France and Germany, were allowed to intervene solely on questions of interpreting the convention.
Human Rights Watch said the ruling will mark a crucial moment in the Rohingya’s quest for justice. It stressed, however, that the case determines the responsibility of the state of Myanmar, not the criminal liability of individuals. The judgment is final and cannot be appealed.
Ripple effects for Gaza and other pending cases
According to Human Rights Watch, four other genocide-related cases are pending before the court: Ukraine v. Russia, South Africa v. Israel, Nicaragua v. Germany and the Democratic Republic of Congo v. Rwanda. In South Africa v. Israel, intervening state Mexico has challenged the court’s strict reading of intent, so whether the standard is loosened or upheld is seen as a guide to the direction of the Gaza case. Israel categorically denies the genocide allegations.
The ruling’s practical force has limits. It is binding on the parties, but if Myanmar does not comply, the other side can only turn to the UN Security Council, which has never used that power. Whether Myanmar, ruled by a military junta since the 2021 coup, will comply with any ruling is uncertain, and the return of Rohingya refugees from camps in Bangladesh remains unresolved.