The White House says US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin will hold their first-ever three-way meeting on the 19th on the sidelines of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, Guangdong. Washington names nuclear arms reduction and the Iran war as core topics, but Beijing has drawn a line on joining trilateral arms control talks, leaving open whether it becomes a ‘21st-century Yalta’ or merely a photo opportunity.
According to the Kyunghyang Shinmun, citing AFP, White House spokesperson Olivia Wales said on the 13th (local time) that Trump will hold a separate trilateral meeting with Xi and Putin during the APEC summit in Shenzhen. The meeting is set for the 19th. It will be the first time the three leaders have met together.
광고 문의 · 300×250Wales said Trump has made clear he will discuss reducing nuclear weapons worldwide and regards nuclear proliferation as very dangerous. An anonymous senior US official said Trump will also raise Iran. Taiwan's Central News Agency reported that Trump told reporters on the 8th that one of his meetings would be with Putin and Xi, and that they would discuss denuclearisation and ending the Iran war.
US and China apart on arms control
The Liberty Times, drawing on CNA, noted that New START, which capped US and Russian strategic arsenals, expired in February. Russia proposed an extension, but Trump rejected it and is demanding a ‘new, improved’ deal that includes China. A senior US administration official told Reuters the talks would open with the issue but that no agreement is expected.
China's position differs. Its foreign ministry said last month that demanding China join so-called trilateral nuclear disarmament talks is unfair, unreasonable and unrealistic. The United Daily News, citing the Wall Street Journal, reported a Chinese official as saying Beijing would not agree to trilateral arms control talks, noting that China's arsenal is far smaller than those of the US and Russia and that it is wary of being locked into an unfavourable framework. Foreign ministry spokesperson Guo Jiakun said last week only that China is in communication with the parties concerned.
The Iran war is another pillar. According to the Liberty Times, full-scale fighting has stopped since US and Israeli strikes on Iran on February 28, but a stalemate persists and the closure of the Strait of Hormuz has unsettled oil and gas prices. With a third of China's crude imports passing through the strait before the war, Beijing has pushed to end the conflict, while analysts say Russia has benefited from higher energy prices.
Ukraine left out; separate US-China bilateral
A senior US official said the US and Russia have a separate negotiating channel on Ukraine that China is not part of, making the topic inappropriate for the trilateral, the Kyunghyang Shinmun reported. The Kremlin had hinted Ukraine could come up, while China regards the war as a European matter. Trump will also hold a bilateral meeting with Xi during his China trip, their fourth since he returned to office last year. No Trump-Putin bilateral has reportedly been scheduled.
South Korean President Lee Jae-myung will also attend the Shenzhen APEC, and the two countries' foreign ministers coordinated a Korea-China summit there at talks in Beijing on the 13th. The Korean Peninsula was not reported as an agenda item for the trilateral, but great-power arms control and Iran-war energy supplies are direct variables for Korea. The messages exchanged at the US-China, Korea-China and trilateral meetings on the same stage may shape Seoul's diplomatic room for manoeuvre.
A Third View
Washington presents the meeting as summit diplomacy to curb proliferation, but Lancaster University professor Simon Mabon told Al Jazeera it would be more theatre than substance and that the three cannot end the Iran or Ukraine conflicts. Some note that the Republicans' heavy losses in last week's midterms may weaken Trump's leverage. China is open to the meeting itself but unwilling to be drawn into a treaty framework it did not help shape; the United Daily News cited a Wall Street Journal report that Beijing wanted the agenda and outcomes fixed in advance.
In Russia, Duma foreign affairs committee chair Pyotr Tolstoy said it could become a ‘new Yalta’, while Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov called trilateral dialogue extremely important but said any agreements cannot be imposed on other countries. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky warned of a ‘21st-century Yalta’ in which great powers redraw spheres of influence, and many in Europe are wary of European security being discussed without Ukraine. The United Daily News, citing Japanese media, said Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi will attend APEC and seek talks with Putin; for Korea, the task is how to make its voice on peninsula denuclearisation and Northeast Asian stability heard amid a great-power triangle.