Russia’s move to place Japan Tobacco’s local units under ‘temporary management’ has rattled the Japanese companies still operating there: staying risks seizure, while leaving means heavy losses.
Citing a Yomiuri Shimbun report, Global Times (Huanqiu) said on the 13th that 65 Japanese companies are still operating in Russia, according to a Yale University survey, including major trading houses, manufacturers and financial institutions. With relations between Tokyo and Moscow at a low and the Russian government moving to control the assets of a large Japanese company, these firms are torn between leaving and staying. Japan’s trade minister has separately said 116 Japanese companies had operations in Russia as of April, so figures vary depending on the measure used.
광고 문의 · 300×250The trigger was Japan Tobacco (JT). According to People’s Daily and other reports, President Vladimir Putin signed decrees on the 5th and 6th of this month placing seven JT subsidiaries in Russia under the temporary management of Russian companies. The step rests on an April 2023 Russian mechanism allowing temporary administration of assets belonging to firms from ‘unfriendly countries’. Japanese media say the units can keep operating and earning profits, but JT has effectively lost control and will struggle to move money out of Russia.
The shock showed in the numbers. JT shares fell limit-down for two straight trading days, and Japanese media estimate losses of up to 1.3 trillion yen if it loses management control, against Russian assets of about 1.5 trillion yen at the end of September. The Japanese government, JT’s largest shareholder, has protested to Moscow several times and demanded the decision be reversed. Trade minister Ryosei Akazawa said the measure had ‘increased uncertainty’ for companies doing business in Russia.
Hard to stay, hard to go
Leaving is costly too, Global Times noted. Under Russian rules, a company from an ‘unfriendly’ country selling its local unit to a Russian buyer can receive no more than 40 percent of market value and must pay 35 percent of market value to the Russian state. In 2022 Denmark’s Carlsberg and France’s Danone each absorbed losses of around one billion euros before selling their Russian businesses cheaply. Ajinomoto chief executive Shigeo Nakamura said the company had not decided whether to exit Russia fully, since leaving could cost it a foothold for any future return.
Moscow insists it is not closing its market. Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova said Russia remains open to fair dialogue with companies that obey Russian law, and Putin said, according to TASS, that Russia would support firms that keep cooperating. A Russian Foreign Ministry official, however, described the takeovers as countermeasures against ‘overtly hostile’ actions by unfriendly countries. A Bloomberg commentary argued that Japan, given its reliance on Russian energy, may be seen as a relatively weak link in the Western sanctions chain.
Corporate risk tied to a diplomatic deep freeze
The episode comes amid a long freeze in bilateral ties. The Japan News, the Yomiuri’s English-language paper, reported that October’s 70th anniversary of the Japan-Soviet Joint Declaration passed with no celebratory mood, and Russia’s unilateral suspension of peace treaty talks after the invasion of Ukraine remains in place. Tokyo says it will keep channels open, partly to protect economic interests such as Japanese stakes in the Sakhalin-2 oil and gas project. A Hokkaido University expert told Global Times that Japanese firms may need to make a ‘rational decision’ to cut losses while they still have some control. It is a cautionary tale for Korean companies, too, which have also been balancing sanctions against market access.