The Dutch lower house approved a 2027 tax plan featuring higher taxes on the wealthy by a single vote, but coalition partner VVD voted against it, raising the spectre of a cabinet collapse. The VVD has, for now, decided to stay.
The Dutch House of Representatives passed Prime Minister Rob Jetten’s 2027 tax plan by 76 votes to 74 on the evening of November 12, DutchNews.nl reported. The catch was that the no votes included the centre-right VVD, one of the three coalition parties. After coalition partners D66 and the Christian Democrats (CDA) backed a wealth tax amendment from the left-wing opposition, the VVD said the coalition agreement had been broken and voted against the whole bill.
광고 문의 · 300×250The amendment, tabled by the left-wing parties PRO and Volt, is a scaled-down version of their ‘millionaires’ tax’. The original aimed to raise 1.5 billion euros; the adopted version raises about one billion euros a year from higher earners and the wealthy. The so-called box 3 tax on savings and investment returns is split into two rates, 35.5 percent on returns up to 60,000 euros a year and 38.5 percent above that, and nearly 900 million euros goes to softening a planned rise in the lowest income tax rate. The amendment also targets ‘paper gifts’, where parents promise money to children on paper to cut inheritance and gift taxes.
D66, CDA, PRO, Volt, 50PLUS, ChristenUnie, Denk and the Party for the Animals (PvdD) voted in favour. DutchNews.nl said the PvdD, which had signalled opposition the day before, switched shortly before the vote after D66 and CDA agreed to raise the tax on private jets and drop a planned rail fare increase. A no-confidence motion from the far-right PVV failed by 116 votes to 34.
A patch-up after seven hours of talks
VVD parliamentary leader Ruben Brekelmans said after the vote that he was “not going to make a decision two minutes after the votes,” calling the day’s events appalling. According to NL Times, after roughly seven hours of meetings on November 13 the VVD decided to remain in the coalition, though Jetten said the “conversation is not yet over” and talks would continue over the weekend. The VVD reportedly wants a ‘correction on substance’ and a different ‘political balance’, and the daily AD reported it could seek to bring another right-wing party into the coalition.
Figures inside the government moved to calm tempers. CDA Deputy Prime Minister Bart van den Brink said that “being angry does not mean you are automatically right,” while Interior Minister Pieter Heerma said the government should carry on. Ironically, the minister responsible for implementing the tax plan is the VVD’s own finance minister, Eelco Heinen. The bill now goes to the Senate, where the minority coalition, less than nine months into its term, also lacks a majority.
The episode illustrates the fragility of minority governments in Europe’s increasingly fragmented parliaments. Coalition partners striking issue-by-issue deals with different opposition parties can get laws passed, but quickly erodes cohesion. Debates over wealth taxes and the business climate are recurring in other European countries under fiscal strain as well.