South Korea’s Financial Services Commission and Financial Supervisory Service unveiled a governance reform plan on Nov. 12 after consultations with the ruling party. A bank holding company chair seeking a third term would need at least three-quarters of the votes present at the shareholders’ meeting, and CEO nomination committees would consist entirely of independent directors.
According to the Seoul Shinmun and Nextdaily, the Financial Services Commission (FSC) and the Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) released the financial company governance improvement plan on Nov. 12 following a party-government meeting with the Democratic Party. Announced in the presence of FSC Chairman Lee Eok-won and FSS Governor Lee Chan-jin, the plan contains 25 tasks spanning laws, enforcement decrees, supervisory rules and best practices. It comes about 11 months after President Lee Jae-myung criticized governance problems at financial firms late last year. Its main aim is to end the practice of sitting CEOs shaping their own succession and reappointment.
광고 문의 · 300×250Tiered thresholds at the committee and the AGM
The rules apply to chairs of bank holding companies without a controlling shareholder. The nomination committee threshold rises from a simple majority of members present to two-thirds for an initial appointment and three-quarters for a reappointment. At the shareholders’ meeting, an initial appointment would need a majority of votes present and at least a quarter of all issued shares; a first reappointment two-thirds and at least a third of issued shares; and a third term or beyond three-quarters and at least half of issued shares. The Seoul Shinmun reported that the plan also separates the CEO appointment vote from director elections.
Nomination committees would be required by law to consist solely of independent directors, and sitting CEOs could not attend meetings that recommend outside director or audit committee candidates. Improper interference could bring penalties ranging from a caution or warning to a suspension of up to six months or a dismissal request. Contacts between a sitting CEO and committee members during succession would not be banned but must be disclosed. The committee chair would have to explain the nomination at the shareholders’ meeting and fall under the responsibility map system, while CEO evaluations would have to reflect financial accidents and sanctions as well as performance.
Shareholder rights would also expand. Shareholders holding at least 0.1 percent for six months or more could nominate outside director candidates; the FSC estimates 1,261 shareholders meet that bar across seven holding companies, excluding NH. A clawback of performance pay from executives who cause losses through intent or gross negligence, and a say-on-pay explanation at shareholder meetings for listed financial firms with assets of 2 trillion won or more, would be written into law. A ban on third terms, considered earlier, was dropped from the final plan over conflicts with global standards and constitutional concerns about freedom of occupation.
Doubts about its effectiveness remain. Nextdaily noted that this year’s reappointment votes far exceeded 75 percent: 88.0 percent for Shinhan Financial Chairman Jin Ok-dong, 99.3 percent for Woori Financial Chairman Im Jong-yong and 91.9 percent for BNK Financial Chairman Bin Dae-in. Analysts say the real hurdle will be the nomination committee rather than the shareholder vote, while critics warn that power could shift to outside directors without matching accountability and that CEO sanction provisions could revive criticism of state-directed finance. The FSC plans to draft the amendment this year, but its passage timing is uncertain, and it would take effect about six months after passage. For ethnic Chinese businesses and retail shareholders in Korea who deal with bank groups, the more transparent selection process is a reason to watch shareholder meeting disclosures more closely.