Three-way talks mediated by the United States in Abu Dhabi on November 10 and 11 ended with agreement only on a large prisoner exchange. Core disputes over territory and a postwar security framework were left for further talks.
U.S.-mediated talks between Russia and Ukraine on ending the war closed in Abu Dhabi on Wednesday, November 11, after two days. It was the first face-to-face three-way round in nine months, since talks in Geneva in February, but the only concrete outcome was an agreement on a large-scale prisoner swap. South Korea's Kyunghyang Shinmun summed up the round as disagreement on territory and other disputes, with only a prisoner exchange agreed, while the Associated Press and Al Jazeera likewise reported no major breakthrough.
광고 문의 · 300×250According to Xinhua and CBS News, Russia's delegation was led by presidential aide Vladimir Medinsky and included Deputy Foreign Ministers Sergei Ryabkov and Mikhail Galuzin and military intelligence chief Igor Kostyukov. Ukraine sent chief negotiator Rustem Umerov and Davyd Arakhamia, parliamentary leader of the ruling Servant of the People party, and Xinhua reported that presidential office head Kyrylo Budanov was also in the delegation. U.S. envoy Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, President Donald Trump's son-in-law, acted as mediators. Neither Russian President Vladimir Putin nor Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky attended.
Kushner said after the talks that 'one of the positives is we agreed that we're going to have the biggest humanitarian release of prisoners,' adding that the numbers would be finalized on November 12. Russia's TASS news agency reported that the exchange should take place within two to three weeks. According to the Kyiv Post, Zelensky had earlier floated swaps of 1,000 or 1,500 prisoners per side, but those were possible formats rather than a confirmed figure. CBS News said humanitarian issues, including the return of Ukrainian civilians in captivity and children taken to Russia, were also on the agenda.
Territory remains the biggest obstacle
Kushner called it 'a very tough meeting but a productive one,' while acknowledging that territory is the hardest issue to resolve. According to the Kyiv Post, Russia is demanding parts of the Donbas its forces have not captured, while Ukraine refuses to cede land or recognize Russian control of occupied areas. Kyiv also reportedly rejected a U.S. proposal to redraw the administrative boundaries of Donetsk and Luhansk. 'No one believes that Putin will stop if we give up the Donbas,' Zelensky said on November 10.
The sides are also far apart on postwar security. Kushner said there was 'progress' on a postwar security framework but that it cannot be implemented until territory and other bilateral issues are settled. Ukraine wants guarantees against another Russian attack, including ways to monitor a ceasefire, while Russia wants a broader discussion of European security that would include guarantees for Moscow such as limits on NATO expansion. Xinhua reported that Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said Russia would not accept a 'truce' or 'ceasefire' while the situation remains unclear.
Europe's role is also unresolved. Representatives of Britain, France, Germany, Italy, NATO and the European Commission were in Abu Dhabi and held separate consultations with the Ukrainian and U.S. delegations, but did not join the main table with Russia. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov had earlier ruled out a European role, saying the three-way format had already been agreed. Medinsky said Russia had held no discussions with the European delegation.
Next stops: Moscow and Dublin
According to Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov, Witkoff and Kushner will meet Putin in Moscow on the morning of November 12 to brief him on the talks and seek further progress, before flying to Dublin, Ireland, to meet Zelensky. Ushakov said Moscow was still assessing the Abu Dhabi results and believed the U.S. envoys were 'bringing something with them.' Umerov said Ukraine's delegation would also meet European officials on November 11.
The war continued outside the negotiating room. CBS News reported that on November 11, the second day of talks, Russian strikes wounded seven civilians in Zaporizhzhia and Kharkiv, and a strike on a market in Odesa killed three people and injured 11. Russia's Defense Ministry said it downed 627 Ukrainian drones overnight, and a fire at Russia's Ust-Luga port injured three workers. The AP noted that little territory has changed hands this year, while Russia's wartime economy is under strain and Ukraine is reeling from attacks on its power grid.
A Third View
The two warring parties offered sharply different readings. Russia's Medinsky said there was understanding on some issues but not on others, and that progress toward peace depended on the positions of Ukraine and the United States and on 'whether Europe will come to its senses.' Ukraine's Umerov spoke of 'huge progress,' while Arakhamia cited 'good momentum' toward a solution before year's end and said the next round should be multilateral, with Europe represented. Zelensky repeated that European security cannot be discussed 'without Europe.'
Washington stressed its achievements as mediator. Secretary of State Marco Rubio called the talks 'very productive' but cautioned that stopping the war would take time. The AP reported, however, that Trump has pushed Kyiv to accept a deal that Zelensky and European allies believe strongly favors Russia. European governments, according to Xinhua, coordinated in advance with the United States, Ukraine and NATO, reaffirming that any arrangement must respect Ukraine's sovereignty, territorial integrity and right to decide for itself, and are pressing for a seat at the table.
China has maintained its long-standing call for a negotiated settlement. Foreign Ministry spokesperson Mao Ning said at a regular briefing in February that China would continue to play a constructive role for peace in its own way and support all efforts for peace, adding that 'peace talks cannot be accomplished at one stroke, but with dialogue there is hope for peace.' This newspaper could not confirm any separate Chinese Foreign Ministry comment on the outcome of the Abu Dhabi round. Earlier this month the ministry said China was in communication with relevant parties about a possible meeting of the Chinese, Russian and U.S. leaders, drawing attention to diplomacy around this month's APEC summit in Shenzhen.
The talks matter for South Korea and the Chinese community living there. Progress or setbacks in peace efforts move international oil and gas prices and, in turn, the won-dollar exchange rate, directly affecting an import-dependent Korean economy and the costs of overseas Chinese merchants in trade and distribution. And since reports of North Korean troops being sent to Russia, Russia-North Korea military cooperation has become a live security issue on the Korean Peninsula, tying the course of the war to the peninsula's own situation. Whether the prisoner swap goes ahead as planned and whether Europe joins the negotiating framework will be the next tests.